State of Things

The Tortilla Aisle Got Serious: A State of Things

It used to be one shelf. Now it's a wall, and most of what's on it is better than what your grandmother could buy.

This one links to gear. Gear links may be affiliate links (Amazon); if you buy through one we may earn a small commission at no cost to you. We only list what we'd buy again. Details.

Twenty years ago the tortilla aisle in most Texas grocery stores was one shelf. Two brands of flour, one of corn, a bag of chips. Today it is a wall, sometimes a refrigerated case, and the quality at the bottom of the range is higher than the top used to be.

This is not a trend piece. It is a field report on something that happened quietly and changed how a lot of people in this state eat on a Tuesday.

What actually changed

Three things, roughly in order.

First, refrigerated tortillas moved out of the specialty case and into the main aisle. A flour tortilla with real fat and no preservative load has a shelf life measured in days, not months. Stores learned they could sell them anyway, because people bought them faster than they spoiled.

Second, small tortillerias started supplying grocery chains instead of only restaurants. The product you used to drive across town for now shows up on a shelf twelve miles from the place that made it, often dated that morning.

Third, corn got better. Nixtamalized corn tortillas, the kind made from whole kernels soaked in lime water instead of reconstituted flour, went from a thing you heard about to a thing you could buy. They taste like corn. The old ones tasted like the bag.

How to read the wall

Stand in front of it and look at three things.

The ingredient list. A good flour tortilla has about five ingredients: flour, water, fat, salt, a leavener. If the list runs to fifteen and includes words you need to sound out, it will keep for two months and taste like it.

The fat. Lard or shortening makes the softest, most pliable flour tortilla. Vegetable oil makes a stiffer one. Butter is rare and expensive and worth trying once. None of these is wrong. They are different tools.

The date. Refrigerated tortillas are a fresh product. Treat the date like you treat milk.

The corn question

Corn tortillas carry more range than flour. At the low end is a product that exists to hold a filling and nothing more. At the high end is a tortilla you would eat plain with salt.

The difference is mostly the corn. Masa made from fresh nixtamal has a smell you can pick up from across the kitchen. Masa made from dehydrated flour is fine, consistent, and flat in flavor. Both are real tortillas. One is worth the extra dollar.

Size matters too. A four-inch street taco tortilla and a six-inch standard are different products for different jobs. Buy the one that matches the job. Doubling up small ones is a habit, not a strategy.

Heat them. Always.

Nobody is eating a cold tortilla out of the bag on purpose. Yet most people heat them wrong, which means a microwave and a paper towel.

The microwave steams. It makes them soft for about ninety seconds, then gummy. A dry pan or a comal does the opposite: it drives off surface moisture, toasts the outside, and wakes up the fat.

Flat, no sides, 10 to 12 inches, works on gas or electric

Carbon Steel Comal (10 to 12 inch)

Heats faster than cast iron and you can flip with your fingers. Every tortilla in this article tastes better after thirty seconds on one.

Thirty seconds a side, flip with your fingers or a spatula, stack them in a towel. A stack of ten stays hot for fifteen minutes that way. That is enough time to eat.

What to expect next

The wall is not getting smaller. More stores are adding a hot case with tortillas pressed in-store. More small producers are getting shelf space. Prices on the good stuff are drifting down as volume goes up, which is how it should work.

The thing to watch is whether the old long-shelf-life product disappears or just moves to the bottom shelf. Probably the bottom shelf. There is a use for a tortilla that keeps for two months in a truck. It is just not dinner.

The short version

Read the ingredient list, check the date, buy the fewer-ingredient package, and heat it on a dry pan. The aisle got serious. You can too, for about a dollar more a dozen.

While you're here