This one links to gear. Gear links may be affiliate links (Amazon); if you buy through one we may earn a small commission at no cost to you. We only list what we'd buy again. Details.
Chili arguments are about three things: beans, tomatoes, and whether ground beef counts. This recipe takes a position on all three without saying a word. Cubed chuck. Whole dried chiles. No beans, no tomato. Three hours.
Make it once and the argument ends, not because you won it but because everyone’s eating.
1. Get the right chiles
The flavor is in the chiles, not the chili powder. Dried whole pods from the Mexican aisle or any Hispanic grocery, where they’re cheap and fresh enough to bend without cracking.
For a pot that serves eight:
- 6 ancho (dried poblano): sweet, raisiny, the body of the sauce
- 4 guajillo: bright, a little tangy, the color
- 2 to 4 chile de arbol: the heat. Two is a warm bowl. Four is a bowl people talk about.
Pull the stems and shake out most of the seeds. Toast the pods in a dry skillet over medium for about 30 seconds a side until they smell like raisins and smoke. Don’t let them blacken; burnt chile is bitter and you can’t fix it.
Cover them with hot water and let them sit 20 minutes. Blend with a cup of the soaking liquid and a half teaspoon of salt until smooth. That paste is the whole recipe.
2. Cut the meat yourself
Three pounds of chuck roast, cut into half-inch to three-quarter-inch cubes. Not ground. Ground beef turns to gravel in three hours; cubes turn to something you can cut with a spoon.
Trim the big slabs of hard fat but leave the marbling. Salt it, about a tablespoon of kosher across the whole batch, and let it sit while the chiles soak.
Enameled Dutch Oven (6 to 7 quart)
Holds heat so the simmer stays at a simmer. Enamel means no reaction with the chiles. The expensive French one does the same thing for four times the price.
Brown it in batches in a tablespoon of fat, high heat, don’t crowd the pot. You want a hard brown crust on the cubes and a dark fond on the bottom. This takes about 20 minutes total and it is the step people skip and then wonder why the chili tastes flat.
3. Build the pot
Pull the meat. Drop the heat to medium. Into the fat goes one large diced onion and a pinch of salt; cook until soft and taking on color, about 8 minutes. Four cloves of garlic, minced, for one minute more.
Toast the dry spices right in the pot for 30 seconds: 2 tablespoons of whole cumin, ground fresh, and a tablespoon of Mexican oregano.
Blade Coffee Grinder (for spices)
Turns toasted cumin into powder in eight seconds. Label it SPICES with a marker or someone will make coffee that tastes like cumin.
Now the chile paste. Stir it in and let it fry in the fat for 2 or 3 minutes until it darkens a shade and smells deep instead of raw. Scrape the bottom.
Meat back in. Add about 3 cups of beef stock, enough to barely cover. One tablespoon of masa harina stirred into a quarter cup of water, poured in. Bring to a simmer.
4. Three hours, lid cracked
Lowest heat the burner has, or a 300 degree oven. Lid on but ajar so steam gets out and the liquid reduces. Stir every 30 minutes and scrape the bottom.
At hour one it looks thin and tastes sharp. At hour two the meat gives when pressed. At hour three a cube falls apart against the side of the pot and the liquid has turned from a sauce into chili. If it’s too thick, splash in stock. If it’s too thin at hour three, lid off for the last 30 minutes.
Taste at the end for salt. It usually needs another teaspoon. A tablespoon of cider vinegar brightens it if it tastes heavy. Don’t skip that.
5. Serve it plain
A bowl of red wants very little. Diced white onion. Shredded cheddar if you must. Saltines or a square of cornbread. Beans on the side in a separate pot for the people who want them, which costs you nothing and ends that argument too.
It’s better the second day. Make it the night before the game, let it sit in the fridge, reheat it low. Freezes for three months.
The short version
Toast and soak 12 dried chiles, blend to a paste. Brown 3 pounds of cubed chuck hard. Onion, garlic, fresh-ground cumin, oregano, fry the paste, meat back in, stock and masa, three hours barely simmering. Salt, a splash of vinegar, serve with onion. Don’t say anything. You won’t have to.