Gear Report

Thermometers, Ranked by How Many Briskets They Saved

Five ways to read the temperature of meat and air. One of them is attached to the lid, and it is last.

This one links to gear. Gear links may be affiliate links (Amazon); if you buy through one we may earn a small commission at no cost to you. We only list what we'd buy again. Details.

Brisket is a fifteen-dollar-a-pound mistake if you get the temperature wrong. The fix is not a bigger pit or a better rub. It is knowing the number, at the grate and in the meat, at the moment you need it. Five tools do that job. They are ranked here by how often each one has actually pulled a cook back from the edge.

1. The instant-read

2 to 3 second read, thin tip, waterproof, backlit

Instant-Read Thermometer (fast, thin tip)

Probe the flat in six places in thirty seconds and know exactly where it stands. The feel of the probe going in tells you more than the number does.

Every brisket that has been saved at this house was saved by this. Around hour ten, when the leave-in probe says 198 and you are not sure, you open the lid and probe the flat in five places. The number tells you the range across the cut. The feel tells you whether it is done. Resistance means more time. Warm butter means pull it.

A fast one matters. A three-second read means the lid is open for thirty seconds. A fifteen-second read means it is open for two minutes and the pit drops 30 degrees. Thin tip matters too; a thick probe leaves a hole that leaks juice.

2. The dual-probe leave-in

Two probes, high and low alarms, 500 F lead rating

Dual-Probe Leave-In Thermometer

Meat on one, grate on the other, alarm set. The only reason an overnight cook is survivable without a cot next to the pit.

This is the one that lets you sleep. One probe in the thickest part of the flat. One clipped to the grate an inch from the meat. Alarm high at 285 and low at 225 for the grate, and 195 for the meat.

It saves briskets by waking you up. The grate alarm at 3 a.m. means the fire is dying and you have ten minutes to fix it before the temperature slides into the zone where bacteria care more than you do. Without it you find out at 6, with a pit at 140 and a brisket you are not sure about anymore.

The grate probe matters more than the meat probe. The meat you can check with the instant-read. The fire you can only check by being awake, and the probe is awake for you.

3. The wireless probe

No wires, app or base unit, 150 to 300 ft range

Wireless Probe Thermometer

Nice to have when the pit is forty yards from the couch. Battery life and range are what the box says about half the time. The wired version does the same job for half the money.

Same job as the dual-probe, without the wire running out from under the lid. The upside is real when the pit is across the yard and the phone is in your pocket. The downside is that the connection is the weak point. Walls, a metal pit lid, and a phone that fell asleep all cut the signal, and a thermometer that stops reporting at 2 a.m. did not save anything.

If the pit is on the patio next to the back door, the wired unit is just as good and cheaper. If it is out by the fence, this is worth it. Charge it before every cook and treat the range on the box as a number somebody wrote in a meeting.

4. The infrared gun

Laser pointer, -58 to 1000 F, adjustable emissivity

Infrared Thermometer Gun

Reads surface temperature from across the yard. Good for grate and cast iron. Useless for meat, which is why it ranks fourth.

Point, pull the trigger, read the surface. It is fast and it feels like the future. It is also measuring the wrong thing for barbecue. It reads the surface temperature of whatever the laser is on, and the surface of a brisket is nowhere near its center. For meat, it is useless.

Where it earns a spot: checking the grate before you sear, checking a cast iron skillet on a side burner, finding the hot spot in a cook chamber so you know which end to put the point toward. Borrow one from the neighbor who bought it for the HVAC and used it once.

5. The lid dial

3-inch dial, bimetal, 100 to 550 F

Replacement Lid Dial Thermometer

It reads air at the top of the chamber, which is not where the meat is, and it is off by 20 to 40 degrees before you start. If yours broke, you lost nothing.

Every smoker ships with one and nearly every one is wrong. The bimetal coil reads air temperature at the top of the chamber, near the lid, a foot above the grate. On a backyard offset that air is 20 to 40 degrees hotter than the grate. On a kettle with the vents open it can run 50 off.

If you cook to the lid dial, you are cooking 30 degrees cooler than you think, your timing is wrong, and your brisket is tough at the hour you planned to serve it. It has never saved a brisket. It has ended a few. Leave the broken one in the lid as a decoration and put a probe at grate level.

The short version

An instant-read and a dual-probe. About $75 together, and between them they cover every decision in a cook. Wireless if the pit is far. IR gun if somebody lends you one. The dial in the lid is a hole with a number in it.

While you're here