How It's Done

How to Light Charcoal Without Lighter Fluid, Once and for All

Four ways, ranked by how fast they work and how little they cost. All of them beat the bottle.

This one links to gear. Gear links may be affiliate links (Amazon); if you buy through one we may earn a small commission at no cost to you. We only list what we'd buy again. Details.

Lighter fluid does one thing well, and that is sell more lighter fluid. It takes twenty to thirty minutes to burn off before you can cook on it, it coats the coals with a smell you can taste on a hot dog, and it is the reason every fourth grill on your street has a scorch mark on the fence behind it.

There are four better ways. Any one of them is faster. All four are cheaper by the end of the summer. Pick one and stop buying the bottle.

The way that works every time: a chimney

Steel, about 6 qt capacity, wood or heat-shield handle

Charcoal Chimney Starter

One sheet of newspaper, fifteen minutes, a full load of grey coals. Lasts a decade if you leave it out of the rain.

A chimney is a steel can with holes at the bottom and a grate partway up. Fill the top with charcoal. Wad up one full sheet of newspaper, or use one starter cube, and put it in the bottom. Set the chimney on the grill grate and light the paper.

Air pulls in through the bottom holes, up through the coals, and out the top. In about fifteen minutes the top coals are grey around the edges and you dump the whole load. Briquettes take closer to twenty. Lump takes closer to twelve.

Dump with welding gloves or the handle shield, not an oven mitt. The can is around 800 degrees at the bottom when you lift it.

The fast way: a torch

Trigger ignition, fits standard 1 lb propane cylinder

Propane Torch Head

Lights a chimney in ninety seconds and a loose pile in five minutes. Also thaws a frozen hose bib in January, so it earns its keep year round.

A propane torch head on a one-pound cylinder lights a chimney from the bottom in about ninety seconds of flame, and you can walk away. It also lights a loose pile of charcoal directly in the grill: hit three or four spots for about thirty seconds each, let them spread. Five minutes to a usable fire for burgers, fifteen for a full bed.

The torch is the answer when it is windy, when the newspaper is wet, or when you are starting a smoker at 5 a.m. and your patience ran out before the coffee did.

The cheap way: starter cubes

Wax and sawdust or wood fiber, about 24 per box, burn 8 to 10 min

Natural Fire Starter Cubes

One cube under a chimney, two under a pile. Odorless, burns in wind, and a box lasts a season. Keep them dry.

Wax-and-sawdust cubes are the no-tool option. One under a chimney replaces the newspaper and does not blow out in a breeze. Two or three in a loose pile of charcoal, with coals mounded on top, lights the pile in about ten minutes. They are about thirty cents each and burn eight to ten minutes, which is long enough for briquettes to catch.

They work in wind, they work damp, and they do not make the grill smell like anything. Store them in a coffee can with a lid. Left in the open box in a Texas garage they soften and stick together by July.

The free way: paper and a cone

If you have no gear at all, build a cone. Crumple two sheets of newspaper into a loose ball in the center of the charcoal grate. Stack charcoal around and over it in a pyramid, leaving gaps for air. Light the paper from the bottom in three places.

This takes twenty minutes and works best with lump, which catches easier than briquettes. It fails in wind and it fails if you pack the pile tight. It is what people did before chimneys were ten dollars at every hardware store, and it still works.

What to do with the lit coals

Once the coals are grey on top, spread them for the cook. For burgers and steaks, bank them to one side so you have a hot zone and a cooler zone. For a long cook, dump them on one end of an unlit bed so the fire creeps across over hours.

Put the lid on with the vents open. Give it five minutes to come up to temperature. Then cook. There is no waiting for anything to burn off, because nothing is on the coals but coal.

Why the fluid is worse than you think

Lighter fluid is a petroleum distillate. It burns off most of the way in twenty minutes if you let it. Most people do not; the coals look ready at ten and the burgers go on. The smell you notice is fuel that did not finish burning. Beyond taste, the fluid-soaked bag of “match light” charcoal is the same stuff pre-applied and costs about double per pound.

A chimney and a box of cubes together cost less than three bottles of fluid. By August you are ahead.

The short version

Chimney with one sheet of newspaper, fifteen minutes. Torch if it is windy or early. Cubes if you want zero tools. A paper cone if you want zero dollars. All four beat the bottle, and none of them taste like a gas station.

While you're here