Gear Report

Six Things Worth Buying for a Backyard Pit, and Four That Aren't

The whole list fits in one trip and costs less than the smoker did. The other four are how the smoker ended up costing more.

This one links to gear. Gear links may be affiliate links (Amazon); if you buy through one we may earn a small commission at no cost to you. We only list what we'd buy again. Details.

A new smoker arrives with a hundred dollars of stuff you do not have, and the barbecue aisle is happy to sell you three hundred dollars of stuff you will never use. Both lists are below. The first six have earned their spot over more cooks than I want to count. The last four were bought, used twice, and now live in the garage with the bread machine.

1. A thermometer that lives in the meat

Two probes, 500 F rated leads, 100 ft range or app

Dual-Probe Leave-In Thermometer

One probe in the meat, one clipped at grate level. It is the only reason you get to sleep during an overnight cook.

The dial on the smoker lid reads the air up top, which runs 20 to 40 degrees off the grate where the meat actually is. A leave-in probe at grate level tells you the truth, and a second probe in the flat tells you when the truth is 203. Set the alarm, go inside. This is the single purchase that turns a twelve-hour cook from a vigil into a nap.

2. Gloves built for welders, not bakers

Split leather, 14-inch cuff, cotton lined

Leather Welding Gloves

Picks up a lit chimney, moves a hot grate, wraps a brisket off the pit. Oven mitts melt. These scorch and keep going.

Oven mitts are rated for a 350-degree oven for a few seconds. A lit chimney is 1,000 degrees and a grate you need to move is 400. Welding gloves are made for grabbing metal that glows. They also go up the forearm, which matters when you lean into a firebox. Two pairs: one stays clean for food, one gets to be filthy.

3. A chimney

Steel, holds about 6 quarts of briquettes

Charcoal Chimney Starter

Fifteen minutes to a full load of lit coals with one sheet of newspaper. Retires the lighter fluid for good.

Fill it, light a sheet of newspaper under it, walk away. Fifteen minutes later the top coals are grey and you dump the whole load. No chemical taste, no squirting fuel at a fire that is already lit, no twenty-minute wait for the fluid to burn off. More on why in the lighter-fluid piece, but the short version is that this twenty-dollar can replaces every bottle you will ever buy.

4. Paper, not foil

18 in x 150 ft, unwaxed, food grade

Pink Butcher Paper Roll

Holds the bark that foil steams off. One roll wraps forty briskets. It also makes a decent tablecloth when company shows up.

Foil traps steam. Steam softens bark, and bark is the part you spent nine hours on. Butcher paper breathes just enough to keep the meat from drying while the crust stays a crust. Wrap at about 165 internal, when the bark is set and the colour is where you want it. One roll is a year of cooking.

5. A stack of throwaway pans

Full size, 3.3 in deep, pack of 15

Disposable Aluminum Steam Pans

Water pan, drip pan, rest pan, transport pan. The same pan does all four, and you throw it away instead of scrubbing it at midnight.

A full-size steam pan is the water pan in the cook chamber, the drip pan under the grate, the rest pan when the brisket comes off, and the pan you carry it to the table in. It costs under two dollars and goes in the trash. The ceramic dish your aunt gave you does not do any of that and takes twenty minutes to clean.

6. A steel bucket with a lid

5 to 6 gallon, tight lid, steel handle

Galvanized Steel Ash Bucket with Lid

Coals stay hot for 24 hours in a pile. In a lidded steel bucket they go out, and the trash can does not. Cheapest insurance in the yard.

Coals buried in ash stay hot for a full day. Every year somebody dumps “cold” ash into a plastic bin or a paper bag and the fire department gets a call. A lidded steel bucket starves the coals and holds the heat where the heat cannot hurt anything. Fill it, lid it, leave it 48 hours, then dump.

Four things to skip

The smoker cover with the brand on it. Sixty dollars for vinyl that bakes brittle in two summers. A twenty-dollar tarp and two bungees does the same job and does not trap moisture against the steel.

Flavored wood pellets or chips for an offset. An offset burns splits. A handful of cherry chips on a post-oak fire changes nothing you can taste. Spend the money on a half cord of wood.

The rib rack. It stands racks on edge so you can fit six. The outside two cook faster than the inside four and you spend the whole cook rotating. Lay them flat and cook fewer, or cook in two rounds.

The injector kit, the mop, the basting brush set. For brisket and ribs in a backyard pit, salt, pepper, and time do the work. Everything in that kit is for a competition table, and you are not at one. If you later find out you are, buy the kit then.

The short version

Thermometer, gloves, chimney, paper, pans, bucket. About $150 total, and you will use every one of them on every cook. The other four are the pit’s way of finding out whether you will buy anything with a flame on the box.

While you're here