This one links to gear. Gear links may be affiliate links (Amazon); if you buy through one we may earn a small commission at no cost to you. We only list what we'd buy again. Details.
A leaning fence post is one of two problems. Either the post rotted at the ground line, which happens to untreated and poorly treated wood in about eight to twelve years here, or the concrete footing was never deep enough and the clay heaved it. Both get fixed the same way: pull the dead one, dig a proper hole, set a new post, let it cure, hang the rails back.
That’s about two hours per post if you have these six tools and a bag of concrete. It’s a quote from a fence company if you don’t.
1. Post hole digger
Post Hole Digger (clamshell)
The only way to dig a hole deeper than it is wide. Fiberglass handles don't crack in the sun the way wood does. Clay will still make you earn it.
A shovel can’t dig a hole that’s eight inches wide and two feet deep. A clamshell digger can. Get one with fiberglass handles; wood handles check and split after a summer leaning against the garage wall.
The hole rule for a six-foot fence: about a third of the above-ground height in the ground, so 24 inches minimum, and around 8 to 10 inches across. Wider at the bottom than the top if you can manage it. That shape resists heaving.
2. Digging bar
Digging Bar / Tamper (steel)
Breaks up the clay the digger can't bite and the old concrete around the dead post. The tamper end packs the backfill. Heavy on purpose.
North and Central Texas clay in July is closer to brick than dirt. The digger bites, hits a hard layer, and stops. The bar breaks that layer into chunks the digger can lift. The chisel end also pries out the old footing, which is the worst ten minutes of the job.
Flip it over and the flat end tamps the backfill around the new post before the concrete goes in. Fifteen pounds of steel doing two jobs.
3. Four-foot level
4-Foot Level
A 2-foot level lies on a 6-foot post. Four feet reads true. Check two faces, not one.
Plumb matters more on a fence post than almost anywhere else, because a post that’s a quarter bubble off at the top throws the whole panel out. A two-foot level on a six-foot post amplifies every bump in the wood. Four feet reads the post, not the grain.
Check two adjacent faces. Brace the post with a couple of scrap boards screwed to stakes once it reads plumb both ways, and don’t touch it again until the concrete sets.
4. Impact driver
Cordless Impact Driver (18V or 20V)
Drives a 3-inch exterior screw through a rail into a post without pre-drilling. A drill does it too, slower and with more stripped heads.
Rails get hung with 3-inch exterior-rated screws, not nails, because screws come back out the next time a post goes. An impact driver sinks them flush in one pull without pre-drilling and without camming out the head. Keep a second battery charged. The first one dies at the last rail every time.
5. Reciprocating saw
Reciprocating Saw (cordless)
Cuts the old post off at the ground and cuts through nails you can't reach. You'll use it twice a year. Neighbors own them.
You need this for two things: cutting the old post off at the ground when it won’t pull, and cutting nails flush where the old rails were. A wood-with-nails blade handles both. This is also the one tool on the list you probably don’t need to own. Everybody has one, and nobody uses theirs.
6. Mason’s line
Mason's Line and Stakes
Run it post to post before you set anything. Eight dollars that keeps the new post from being the one everyone can see is crooked.
Before you set the new post, run a line from the top of the sound post on one side to the top of the sound post on the other. Set the new post to the line. Without it, the new post is plumb and still looks wrong, because the fence itself isn’t straight and you just made that obvious.
The one bag
Fast-setting concrete mix, 50 pounds. For a standard 8-inch by 24-inch hole with a 4x4 in it, one bag usually does it; two if you dug wide or deep. You don’t mix it. Pour dry mix into the hole around the braced post, add water per the bag, and it takes a set in roughly 20 to 40 minutes. Slope the top so water runs away from the post, not toward it.
Leave about two inches of gravel in the bottom of the hole under the post so the end grain isn’t sitting in a cup of water. That’s the difference between a post that lasts ten years and one that lasts twenty.
The short version
Dig to a third of the height, break the clay with the bar, plumb with four feet of level, set to a string, brace it, one bag of fast-set, and leave it overnight. Six tools, one bag, Saturday morning. Borrow the saw.