Gear Report

Tie-Down Straps, Tested the Only Way That Matters: On the Highway

Everything stays put in the driveway. Seventy miles an hour and a crosswind is where straps get honest.

This one links to gear. Gear links may be affiliate links (Amazon); if you buy through one we may earn a small commission at no cost to you. We only list what we'd buy again. Details.

A strap that holds in the driveway tells you nothing. A load is still at idle. The test is seventy miles an hour into a crosswind on 287 with a truck in front of you kicking up gravel, for two hours, in July, with the webbing baking at 150 degrees on the sunny side. That’s what we did, repeatedly, mostly because we had to haul stuff anyway.

Here is what held and what didn’t. Working loads below are typical for the class, not promises; the tag on your strap is the number that counts.

The everyday strap

1 in. wide, 15 ft, about 500 lb working load each, S-hooks with keepers

1-Inch Ratchet Straps (4-pack, S-hooks)

The everyday strap. Holds a mower, a fridge, a stack of lumber. Loses to anything sharp-edged and to UV after two summers.

A four-pack of one-inch ratchets is the strap most trucks carry, and for most loads it’s right. A zero-turn mower, a refrigerator standing up, a stack of 2x6s, a dresser. Two straps in an X, cranked firm, and nothing moved in two hundred highway miles.

Where it fails: edges and sun. The webbing is thin. A strap over the corner of a steel bed rail or a sharp pallet edge started to fuzz in one trip and cut halfway through in three. And a strap left on the headache rack through one summer lost enough strength that it felt different in the hand, stiff and faded. Toss those. New straps are cheap; a mower in the fast lane is not.

The S-hooks also walk off a stake pocket when the load shifts and the strap goes slack for half a second. Buy the kind with wire keepers, or tie off the hook end.

The strap for things with engines

2 in. wide, 27 ft, about 3,300 lb working load each, flat hooks

2-Inch Ratchet Straps (flat hooks)

For anything with an engine or a frame. Flat hooks seat in trailer D-rings and stake pockets without walking out at speed.

Two-inch ratchets with flat hooks are a different tool. The webbing is twice as wide, the working load is six or seven times higher, and the flat hook sits in a trailer D-ring or a bed stake pocket flat, where it stays. We moved a 700-pound engine on a stand, a riding mower on a trailer, and a 500-gallon water tank. Nothing budged, and after the first ten miles nothing needed a re-crank.

The ratchet itself is the weak point on the cheap ones. If the handle feels gritty or the pawl skips when you crank, don’t trust it. A good ratchet mechanism clicks clean and releases on purpose, not on its own.

Buy two, not four. Four 2-inch straps weigh as much as a toolbox and you’ll leave them at home.

The strap for things you don’t want to crush

1 in. wide, 12 ft, about 250 lb working load, no ratchet

Cam Buckle Straps (1-inch)

For coolers, kayaks, ladders and anything a ratchet would crush. Needs a re-tug at the first gas stop, every time.

A cam buckle has no ratchet. You pull it tight by hand and a spring cam holds it. It can’t over-tighten, which is why it’s right for a kayak, a cooler, a ladder, a bike on a rack, or a cardboard box of anything.

It also can’t hold tension the way a ratchet does. Webbing stretches a little when it warms up and loads settle in the first few miles. Every cam strap we ran was finger-loose at the first stop. Re-tug and it was fine the rest of the way. Just plan the stop.

The one for a car on a trailer

Fits 13 to 18 in. tires, about 3,300 lb working load

Wheel Net / Tire Bonnet Straps

The right answer for a vehicle on a trailer. Wrong answer for everything else, and you'll own them for one job a year.

Wheel nets go over the tire and pull straight down to the trailer, which lets the vehicle’s suspension do its job instead of fighting the strap. They’re the right answer for that job and only that job. If you tow a car twice a year, borrow them from the person who tows one every week. If you are that person, you already own them.

The one you keep buying and shouldn’t

Rubber core, plastic-coated hooks, 18 to 40 in.

Bungee Cords (assorted)

Holds a tarp down. That's it. Anything you'd be upset to lose on I-35 gets a strap.

Bungees hold a tarp down and a trash can lid shut. Stop there. The rubber loses stretch in one summer, the hooks straighten under a real load, and a bungee that lets go at speed is a hook moving at seventy miles an hour toward whoever’s behind you. We’ve seen the coating cracked off of a two-year-old one with a chalky core underneath. That was one holding nothing but a tarp, which is the one thing it’s for.

The thing that saves the straps

Molded plastic or rubber, slides onto 2 in. webbing

Strap Edge Protectors (corner guards)

The cheapest way to make a strap last. Every cut strap we've had was cut on a corner these would have covered.

Every strap we’ve cut was cut on a corner. Bed rail, steel pallet, the edge of a toolbox. A molded corner guard between the strap and the edge is twelve dollars and makes a 25-dollar set of straps last three times as long. A folded shop rag or a piece of garden hose slit lengthwise does the job too. Just don’t put a strap over a sharp edge and hope.

The short version

One-inch ratchets for most loads, two-inch flat hooks for anything heavy or with a frame, cam buckles for anything soft. Corner guards for all of them. Replace any strap that’s faded, fuzzed or cut. Bungees are for tarps.

While you're here